Using Shading in Coefficient Plots

Having recently discovered the R package denstrip, I was struck by intuitive it is to use shading to express uncertainty. If you need convincing, check out the paper by Jennifer Lundquist and Ken Lin linked below.

coefplot.fadeI wondered whether this would also work well for generic coefficient plots to examine regression results. The proof is in the pudding, so here’s some quickly thrown together code (also on Gist).

fade <- function(x, labels=names(coef(x)), expo=FALSE, xlab="", ylab="", bty="n", ...) {
# argument: a regression, additional arguments passed on to plot() and text()
coe <- summary(x)$coefficients[,1] # extract coefficients
cse <- summary(x)$coefficients[,2] # standard errors
len <- length(coe) # how many coefficients (without intercept)
if(expo == TRUE) { # exponential form
coe <- exp(coe)
cse <- exp(cse)
ran <- c(min(coe)- 3*max(cse), max(coe)+3*max(cse)) # range of values
plot(0, ylim=c(1.5,len+0.5), xlim=ran, xlab=xlab, ylab=ylab, bty=bty, type="n", ..., axes=FALSE) # empty plot
# title, xlab, ylab, etc. can be used here.
for(i in 2:len) {
dens <- rnorm(mean=coe[i], sd=cse[i], n=1000)
denstrip(dens, at=i) # passing arguments conflicts with plot()
text(ran[1],i, labels[i], adj = c(0,0), ...) # adj to left-align
# cex, col can be used here

Well, it does work (see figure above). If we add an abline(v=0, lty=3), we can easily highlight the zero line.

coefplot.armHowever, intuitive as it is, I’m not really convinced. Here’s the coefficient plot the arm package produces. While it doesn’t use shading, lines of different thickness are used to indicate the standard errors — nicely de-emphasizing the end-point. There’s more emphasis on the point estimate (i.e. the coefficient itself: the square), while my code hides this. I did try adding a white line at the point estimate (third figure, below), but this doesn’t resolve my biggest worry: the amount of ink that is used to convey the message… I’m just not convinced that the shading adds that much to the relatively simple coefficient plots in the package arm.


(There’s an argument width that could be added to line calling denstrip, like width=0.2, but it hasn’t convinced me enough.)

Jackson, Christopher H. 2008. “Displaying Uncertainty with Shading.” The American Statistician 62 (4): 340–47. doi:10.1198/000313008X370843.

Lundquist, Jennifer H., and Ken-Hou Lin. 2015. “Is Love (Color) Blind? The Economy of Race among Gay and Straight Daters.” Social Forces, March, sov008. doi:10.1093/sf/sov008.

One thought on “Using Shading in Coefficient Plots

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s